Share This Blog Post
What eBay’s Best Offer feature actually does
Best Offer lets a buyer propose a price below your listed Buy It Now price, right from the listing page. You can accept it, decline it, or send back a counter-offer — and so can they, back and forth, until someone accepts or the offer expires. It’s available on fixed-price listings, not auction-format ones, and it’s one of the more underused levers on eBay: buyers actively filter search results to show Best Offer listings only, which means turning it off doesn’t just remove negotiation, it removes you from a slice of search entirely.
Auto-accept and auto-decline: the part that actually saves you time
Left on manual, Best Offer means every offer sits in your inbox waiting for a response — and eBay gives buyers up to 48 hours before an unanswered offer expires. Most sellers who actually use eBay’s auto-accept and auto-decline settings never see the bulk of their offers at all. Set an auto-accept price and any offer at or above it is accepted instantly. Set an auto-decline price and anything below it is rejected automatically — no notification, no reply needed, no back-and-forth.
One detail worth knowing before you rely on it: any offer that includes a buyer comment skips auto-accept entirely and lands in your inbox for a manual look, even if the price clears your threshold. Auto-decline isn’t affected by comments the same way — a low offer gets declined regardless of what’s written alongside it.
Setting thresholds that actually protect your margin
The starting point is knowing your real floor: cost of goods, plus eBay’s final value fee, plus shipping. Whatever’s left above that is your actual room to negotiate. A common approach is listing meaningfully above that floor — enough that a buyer feels like they got a deal by offering below it — then setting auto-accept at or just above the floor plus a small margin, and auto-decline low enough to filter out lowball offers without needing you to look at them.
The trade-off is real: set auto-accept too close to your ceiling and you’ll decline offers a human seller would have taken; set it too close to your floor and you’re leaving margin on the table on every accepted offer. There’s no universal number here — it depends on your category, your margin, and how much manual review time you’re willing to trade for convenience.
When a personal reply beats auto-accept
Automation handles the easy cases, but a well-timed human counter-offer still has a place — particularly on higher-value items, or when you’re online and can respond to a live offer within minutes rather than making a buyer wait out the clock. eBay also lets sellers proactively send offers to buyers who’ve watched an item without purchasing, which pairs naturally with Best Offer to move stock that’s stalled rather than waiting for an offer to come in.
Why Best Offer performs better on a listing that’s actually optimised
Best Offer doesn’t work in isolation — it only gets used on listings buyers find and trust enough to negotiate on in the first place. A listing with clear photos, complete item specifics, and a well-structured description gets more offers, and higher ones, than a sparse listing at the same price. If you’re running Best Offer across a large catalogue, eBay Bulk Revision lets you update pricing, thresholds, and listing details across many items in one action instead of adjusting them one at a time as your floor prices shift.
Common questions
How long does a Best Offer last before it expires? Up to 48 hours if neither side responds — though most active buyers move on well before that window closes, so a fast reply matters more than the technical deadline.
Does Best Offer work on auction-style listings? No — it’s a fixed-price (Buy It Now) feature. On auction listings, any Best Offer option disappears the moment the first bid comes in.
Can I turn Best Offer off after I’ve already listed an item? Yes, by revising the listing — though if there’s a pending offer on it, you’ll need to decline that offer first before the option to remove Best Offer becomes available.
Will accepting a lower offer through Best Offer still cost me the full final value fee? Yes — eBay’s final value fee is calculated on whatever price the item actually sells for, including an accepted Best Offer, the same as it would be on a Buy It Now sale at that price.
What to do next
If Best Offer is switched on across your catalogue but you’re still manually reviewing every offer, setting real auto-accept and auto-decline thresholds is the fastest change you can make this week. And if your listings themselves are the reason offers are coming in low, see how Frooition’s eBay SEO service helps listings earn the kind of trust that gets you better opening offers in the first place.
